Directed by Steven Shainberg, Secretary (2002) is a provocative and emotionally complex romantic drama that blends dark comedy, eroticism, and tenderness to tell a story of two people who discover themselves—and each other—through an unconventional relationship. Far from a sensationalized depiction of taboo desires, the film is a layered exploration of dominance, submission, self-discovery, and intimacy, anchored by two unforgettable performances from Maggie Gyllenhaal and James Spader.
Plot Overview
The film follows Lee Holloway (Maggie Gyllenhaal), a young woman recently released from a mental institution after struggling with self-harm and low self-esteem. Returning to her family, she attempts to rebuild her life and finds work as a secretary for Edward Grey (James Spader), a demanding and eccentric attorney.
At first, Lee is timid, awkward, and easily overwhelmed by Edward’s rigid expectations. But Edward soon notices her submissive tendencies and begins to push her boundaries with strict, sometimes demeaning tasks. What begins as professional discipline transforms into a sadomasochistic relationship, where Edward takes control and Lee finds, to her surprise, empowerment and self-acceptance in her submission.
Themes
1. BDSM and Power Dynamics
Rather than sensationalizing BDSM, Secretary presents it as a mutually fulfilling form of intimacy. The relationship is not framed as exploitation but as a consensual dynamic that helps both characters confront their insecurities.
2. Self-Discovery and Empowerment
Lee’s journey is central to the narrative. Initially fragile and dependent, she evolves into a woman who embraces her desires without shame. Her submission is not portrayed as weakness but as an active, empowering choice.
3. Fear and Vulnerability
Edward struggles with his own desires, haunted by guilt and uncertainty. His internal conflict adds depth to his character, as he vacillates between pushing Lee away and accepting the bond they share.
4. Love Beyond Norms
The film challenges traditional depictions of romance by presenting a relationship that, while unconventional, is deeply nurturing and authentic. It suggests that love can flourish when partners trust and accept each other’s needs, even when those needs fall outside societal expectations.
Performances
-
Maggie Gyllenhaal delivers a fearless and career-defining performance. She embodies Lee’s vulnerability, awkwardness, and eventual transformation into a confident, self-possessed woman who takes ownership of her desires.
-
James Spader brings depth to Edward Grey, portraying him as simultaneously domineering and fragile, oscillating between control and self-doubt. His performance avoids caricature, instead highlighting the humanity beneath the eccentric exterior.
Together, their chemistry creates a relationship that feels believable, unsettling, and strangely tender.
Cinematic Style
-
Tone: The film balances dark humor with moments of genuine warmth, preventing the subject matter from becoming overly heavy.
-
Visuals: Muted colors and minimalistic set design reflect the sterile rigidity of Edward’s world, contrasted by Lee’s emotional awakening.
-
Dialogue: Sharp, often witty, and carefully restrained, it underscores the tension without slipping into melodrama.
Shainberg frames the story not as an erotic spectacle but as a quirky love story, allowing audiences to focus on character development rather than shock value.
The Climax
The emotional high point arrives when Lee demonstrates her commitment to Edward not through passivity but through an act of active, unwavering choice. This moment redefines the power dynamic: Lee is not simply controlled but is a willing participant, solidifying the relationship as one of mutual acceptance and need.
Legacy and Impact
Upon release, Secretary sparked significant conversation for its frank, nonjudgmental depiction of BDSM and its refusal to punish its characters for their desires. Unlike traditional Hollywood romances, it presented intimacy outside the norm as valid, healing, and deeply human.
The film remains a touchstone in discussions of:
-
BDSM representation in cinema.
-
Female empowerment through unconventional roles.
-
Subverting the romantic drama genre with bold, unapologetic storytelling.
Conclusion
Secretary (2002) is not just a film about dominance and submission; it is a nuanced love story about two damaged individuals who find wholeness in each other. By presenting BDSM as a path to self-discovery, healing, and authentic intimacy, it redefines what romance on screen can look like.
With fearless performances, sharp direction, and a mix of dark humor and tenderness, Secretary remains one of the most daring and thought-provoking explorations of love in modern cinema—one where vulnerability and desire intertwine to create something truly transformative.