In the winter of 1956, Chicago was swept up in a tragedy that would go on to haunt the city for decades—not just emotionally, but some say spiritually. On December 28, teenage sisters Patricia (15) and Barbara Grimes (13) set out to catch a screening of Love Me Tender, the newest Elvis Presley film, at the Brighton Theater in the city’s South Side.
They never came home.
What followed was one of the largest missing persons investigations in Chicago history. The disappearance captivated the public, consumed the media, and pushed law enforcement into a state of desperation. But despite an avalanche of tips, dead ends, and shattered leads, the truth of what happened to the Grimes sisters remains unsolved to this day.
Even worse: it’s never rested.
That Night at the Theater
It was a cold Thursday evening when the Grimes girls left their McKinley Park home with a few coins and a shared love of Elvis. They were seen purchasing tickets and even spotted inside the Brighton Theater around 9:30 p.m., during the second showing. But after that, they vanished.
They never made it home. There was no sign of struggle, no known enemies, no ransom. Just two girls gone—leaving behind worried parents and an entire city thrown into fear.
A City Obsessed
The Grimes case became national news. Authorities launched a massive search involving over 300 police officers, sheriff’s deputies, and volunteers. Over 15,000 people were questioned, and tips poured in from across Illinois and beyond.
Some claimed to have seen the girls at diners, bus stations, or hitchhiking. Others said they had run away to meet Elvis in Memphis. Theories ranged from abduction to cult activity to police corruption. Even Elvis Presley himself issued a public plea for the girls to return home.
But the weeks dragged on, and hope began to fade.
The Discovery: A Horrifying End
On January 22, 1957—25 days after they vanished—the frozen, nude bodies of Patricia and Barbara were discovered near Devil’s Creek, just outside of Willow Springs, on the edge of a desolate, wooded ravine. They had been tossed beside the road, left like garbage beneath a blanket of snow.
The official cause of death? Inconclusive. While some evidence suggested exposure to cold, others found signs of possible sexual assault and head trauma. The girls had been killed elsewhere, then dumped along the roadside in a grim, final insult.
Whoever left them there wanted them found—but not too soon.
A House in the Woods, and a Ghost Story Born
Not far from the site where the girls’ bodies were found, a small house sat hidden among the trees, its windows dark and secrets deeper. The family who lived there abandoned it shortly after the girls were discovered, never explaining why. They left behind furniture, belongings—even dishes in the sink. The house quickly fell into ruin.
Locals say it was never right after the discovery. Those who dared to approach the home reported:
-
Cold spots in the middle of summer
-
Disembodied voices, sometimes crying, other times whispering unintelligibly
-
A pair of pale girls, glimpsed through the broken windows or wandering near the tree line
-
Doors slamming shut in an otherwise empty house
-
Radios and car engines failing near the property
It didn’t take long for rumors to take root: the Grimes sisters were haunting the house. And perhaps they were angry.
Eventually, the house was burned to the ground by vandals. Whether out of boredom or fear, no one knows. But even the scorched earth left behind feels tainted. Hikers and thrill-seekers who wander too close to the former foundation report a feeling of unease, as though being watched… or warned.
Theories and Suspects: Justice That Never Came
The investigation never yielded closure.
Police focused on a drifter named Benny Bedwell, who confessed—then recanted, his story full of inconsistencies. He was released. Other suspects came and went. Some locals believed the girls knew their killer. Others blamed organized crime, a perverted predator, or a cover-up that reached into law enforcement.
Despite the exhaustive efforts, the Grimes case eventually went cold. Officially, no one was ever charged. No motive was confirmed. The city simply had to live with the loss.
A Legacy of Sorrow
The deaths of Patricia and Barbara Grimes didn’t just devastate their family—it shook Chicago’s psyche. It was the end of innocence for a postwar generation that still believed in unlocked doors and public trust. Parents grew more protective. Children became more cautious. And the woods near Devil’s Creek became a place of mourning and myth.
Their graves lie side by side in Holy Sepulchre Cemetery, marked by soft stone but shadowed by lingering questions.
Conclusion: Echoes in the Trees
The Grimes sisters were young, joyful, and full of life—two teenagers who wanted nothing more than to dance to Elvis and dream big in a hopeful America. But someone, somewhere, decided their story would end too soon. And then left them to freeze in the dark.
To this day, Chicago remembers them—not just as victims, but as a chilling reminder of how evil can slip in when no one’s looking. And perhaps, in the rustling trees near the ravine where they were found, or in the ruins of a house that couldn’t hold its silence, their spirits still search—not just for peace, but for justice never served.