Computed tomography (CT) scans are among the most powerful diagnostic tools in modern medicine. From detecting strokes and tumors to guiding emergency trauma care, CT scans have revolutionized how doctors see inside the body. But alongside these benefits, a new large-scale study published in JAMA Internal Medicine raises an alarming concern: CT scans may be contributing to over 100,000 new cancer cases each year in the United States, accounting for roughly 5% of all cancer diagnoses.
This revelation highlights the importance of balancing the life-saving benefits of imaging with the risks posed by radiation exposure.
The Scope of the Problem: CT Scans on the Rise
-
In 2023 alone, U.S. hospitals and clinics performed a record 93 million CT scans.
-
Usage has skyrocketed over the past two decades as CT imaging became faster, cheaper, and more widely available.
-
While CT scans often save lives, experts caution that they may be overused in cases where safer alternatives could suffice.
The new study quantified the risk, suggesting that radiation from CT scans may directly contribute to about 100,000 cancer cases annually.
Why CT Scans Pose a Risk
The danger lies in ionizing radiation — high-energy waves that CT machines use to produce detailed cross-sectional images of the body.
-
DNA Damage: Radiation can break chemical bonds in DNA. If the damage is not repaired correctly, it can result in mutations that trigger cancer.
-
Cumulative Exposure: Each CT scan adds to a person’s lifetime radiation dose. The risk is higher for people who undergo multiple scans.
-
Vulnerability in Children: Children are especially sensitive because their cells divide more rapidly, and they have more years ahead in which a cancer could develop.
In fact, research has shown that even a single scan in childhood may raise the chance of developing blood cancers such as leukemia or lymphoma.
Who Is Most at Risk?
The JAMA study emphasizes that risk varies depending on age, health, and genetics:
-
Children and Adolescents: Their rapidly dividing cells and longer life expectancy amplify the risk.
-
People With Genetic Conditions: Those with syndromes such as Lynch syndrome or other DNA repair deficiencies are more susceptible to radiation-induced mutations.
-
Patients With Chronic Illnesses: Individuals requiring repeated scans for monitoring conditions (e.g., Crohn’s disease, kidney stones, or cancer surveillance) face cumulative risks.
How CT Scan Risks Compare to Benefits
It’s important to put these findings into context. CT scans are often lifesaving and irreplaceable:
-
They can detect internal bleeding in minutes, guiding trauma surgeons in emergencies.
-
They are vital for stroke diagnosis, where every second counts in preventing brain damage.
-
They help detect and monitor cancers, infections, and heart disease that other imaging methods may miss.
As Dr. Rebecca Smith-Bindman of UCSF emphasized:
“We need smarter imaging, not more imaging.”
The point is not to avoid CT scans altogether, but to use them wisely and only when medically necessary.
Alternatives to Consider
Whenever possible, doctors and patients should discuss safer imaging alternatives:
-
Ultrasound: Uses sound waves, safe for pregnant women and children. Best for imaging soft tissues, organs, and blood flow.
-
MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging): Uses magnetic fields and radio waves instead of radiation. Ideal for brain, spine, and joint imaging.
-
Low-Dose CT: For patients who must undergo repeated scans, low-dose protocols reduce radiation exposure significantly.
What Patients Can Do
If you or a loved one are facing a CT scan, here are key steps to protect yourself:
-
Ask if it’s truly necessary – Could an ultrasound or MRI provide the same information?
-
Choose accredited imaging centers – Facilities certified by programs like the American College of Radiology often follow stricter safety protocols.
-
Keep track of your scans – Maintain a personal record of all past CTs to avoid unnecessary repeats.
-
Inquire about dose optimization – Newer machines and software can reduce radiation exposure by up to 50% without compromising image quality.
The Path Forward: Smarter Imaging
The medical community is not advocating for an end to CT scans — far from it. Instead, researchers and clinicians are calling for:
-
Stricter guidelines on when CT scans are appropriate.
-
Increased use of alternatives in non-emergency situations.
-
Improved public awareness about the risks and benefits.
-
Ongoing innovation in imaging technology to minimize radiation without losing diagnostic accuracy.
Conclusion: Balance, Not Fear
The news that CT scans may be linked to over 100,000 new cancer cases annually is sobering, but it should not spark panic. Instead, it should serve as a call to action for patients and healthcare providers to be more thoughtful about imaging choices.
CT scans save countless lives each year, but like any medical tool, they must be used with care. By ensuring each scan is truly necessary, choosing safer alternatives when possible, and minimizing exposure through technology and best practices, we can preserve the benefits of CT scans while reducing their risks.
In the end, the goal isn’t fewer scans — it’s smarter, safer imaging for everyone.